Captain Jack

02/02/13 2:15 AM

John Taylor ThornBelle Grove 1894

John Taylor Thorn
Belle Grove 1894

I thought it would be good to get back to the history of Belle Grove and continue this journey. When we last spoke, it was 1906.  In an article from the Free Lance Star of Fredericksburg dated October 4, 1906, we learn that the Thornton Family’s time at Belle Grove has come to an end. John Thornton would sell Belle Grove to Captain J.F. Jack of Los Angeles, California. Captain Jack already owns Walsingham, the plantation just next door. In the time of the Turners, Walsingham was owned by George Turner while Carolinus Turner owned Belle Grove. George was Carolinus’s cousin. By combining the two plantations, there would be 1,400 acres of farm land.

Captain Jack will not take Belle Grove until January, 1907. He would live at Belle Grove in the mansion. Walsingham had lost its beautiful home years before.

In the second article from The Times-Dispatch of Richmond dated October 4, 1906 we find out that Captain Jack purchased Belle Grove for $22,000. Not a bad profit for John Thornton of $13,000.

Belle Grove Sold
Free Lance Star Fredericksburg 10-04-1906
Belle Grove Sold to Californian
The Times-Dispatch Richmond 10-04-1906

But who was this Californian that purchased these two beautiful plantations? This has been a question for us for a long time. In all the research I have done on the plantation, this is one of the owners whose past has been hard to uncover. Believe it or not, I found more on the Colonial Period of this plantation than I have with the owners of the early 1900s.

From what I have uncovered, Captain Jack was an experimental farmer from California. He arrived in Virginia in the early 1900s with the goal to find out if alfalfa would grow in Virginia. As far as the personal side of Captain Jack, the only information I have is that he was from Los Angeles, California. Once again I had to turn to newspapers to build something of a history of him.

The first time we found Captain Jack in the newspaper was in February 1907. He would have owned Belle Grove for about four months at this point. In this article, it reports that Captain Jack has shipped a “carload of very handsome young mules”. It even gives us how many are in a “carload”. There were 24 total and they came from Kentucky.

1907 February 22  Shenandoah Herald

1907 February 22 Shenandoah Herald

The next article gives us more insight into why Captain Jack moved to Virginia. We know he was an experimental farmer, but from reading this article, it seems that he was also here to teach. In the summer months of 1909, The Farmers Institute put on a cruise down the Rappahannock River with the goal to give local farmers the opportunity to hear about new and more modern methods of farming. This cruise which started in Fredericksburg was headed by “Commodore” George Wellington Koiner, Commissioner of Agriculture and Immigration and several instructors. Touring on the good ship “Gratitude” they would touch eight counties and their farmers along the Rappahannock River.

One of the speakers was Captain Jack of Belle Grove. They speak of how Captain Jack of Port Conway was a successful alfalfa hay-maker. He was to “explain to the farmers how he came to sell out his possessions in California to come to Virginia soil to make alfalfa and what wonderful success has followed his efforts.” Known locally as “Alfalfa Jack”, he would tell how he came to Virginia in 1906 and spent several months traveling the area and observing “the general conditions with the respect to alfalfa growing.” He had observed that alfalfa could be grown in small quantities, but what he wanted to know is if it could be produced for commercial purposes and in large enough quantities to make it profitable.

Once he had determined that the area was sufficient to justify the venture, he set forth to find the right place to do it. The land he was looking for “must be slightly undulating, but not rough or steep, that would not wash, that was not too sandy or too loose, too stiff or cold and clammy, not too stony, not too spongy, that was not too wet or too dry, that was well drained, not so badly “worn” as to be unresponsive to treatment, that was on good water transportation, within easy access of some of the great markets of the East and where lime could be obtained at a cost that would admit of its use in liberal quantities’.” Whew… He wasn’t too picky was he?

He would find this land in the two plantation estates of Belle Grove and Walsingham. He states that the soils of these plantations were greatly depleted, but he felt that they had a character that would respond quickly to treatment. With the aid of crimson clover and cowpeas and a liberal application of fertilizer and lime, he felt that he could create alfalfa fields that would compare to the best in the East or West.

After two years, however, he found that the soil was more depleted that thought and it was taking a lot longer to ready the soil. At this point Captain Jack had only 300 acres of alfalfa, but was expecting to plant 200 acres more next fall. Plus he had several hundred more filled with crimson clover and cowpeas ready to be plowed under for future fields. Captain Jack felt that with crimson clover and cowpeas as aids, if used throughout Virginia, the state would soon stand “in the front ranks for fertility and production.”

It states that Captain Jack was still working on adding to his acreage and that by one year he was expected to have over 1,000 acres. He stated that the coming year of 1908, he was expecting to yield just under 4 tons an acre and without advertising or marketing and through shipment by steamer from the Port Conway wharf, he felt that the price would be better than most. He also saw that in the coming years the demand and price would increase as the product became better known in the East.

He explained though that before undertaking this crop, one had to know the plant and everything that it needed. He states that alfalfa has a “mind of its own” and it knows what it wants and needs. And if a farmer took on this crop without the right knowledge, he would lose his investment.

Captain Jack summoned up his thoughts:

“For him who understands its language and unsparingly supplied it needs, it will clothe his fields in beauty, supply his herds with food, enrich his soil, multiply the value of his land and lay its richest treasure at his feet in grateful acknowledgment of his toll and care. I believe that before many years Old Virginia will have many income producing alfalfa farms. It is a result well worth striving for. It is the crop which more than all others will redeem the lands of the Southern and Eastern States – lands which in so many ways have been so wonderfully favored.”

1909 May 30 Richmond Times Dispatch

1909 May 30 Richmond Times Dispatch

In 1909, we find our next piece which is more of a social note in the newspaper. It doesn’t talk about Captain Jack, but it speaks of Mrs. C. Shirley Carter who is a guest at Belle Grove. She is visiting her son, C. Shirley Carter. I haven’t had a chance to research this name, but it is strange to me to see both mother and son with the same name.

1909 October 18 Richmond Times Dispatch

1909 October 18 Richmond Times Dispatch

Almost three years has now gone by since the article about how Captain Jack was building his alfalfa fields. By 1910, we see from this article that Belle Grove has become a noted success in alfalfa.

1910 May 19 The Free Lance Star

1910 May 19 The Free Lance Star

In the summer of 1910, another social note in the newspaper talks about a visit from Miss Minnie King of Richmond. She is to be a guest of Miss Lille Taylor of Belle Grove. While this is another name I haven’t done research on yet, we can assume that they are farm hand workers and their families on the plantation.

1910 June 04 The Free Lance Star

1910 June 04 The Free Lance Star

Also in the summer months, not only were farm hands and their families getting visitors, by is seems Captain Jack received a guest too. A local Stafford farmer traveled to Belle Grove and Walsingham to see Captain Jack and his successful alfalfa fields. There had already been a 400 ton cutting that was waiting to be shipped. And in only ten days another 400 tons was to be cut. Captain Jack amazed his visitors with his success and his modern farming methods.

1910 June 25 Free Lance Star

1910 June 25 Free Lance Star

Another article in the summer of 1910, just three years after the “Farmers College” tour down the Rappahannock, the first report of the success of that “teaching cruise” had started coming in. It talks about the apparent success of farmers all the way from Fredericksburg to the Chesapeake Bay giving evidence of this success from the appearance of houses, barns, fences and fields along the river.

In Port Conway, after proving his modern method, Captain Jack has also started showing signs of success. He has built a new wharf for shipping his alfalfa and a new more roomy warehouse. He has also installed an ornamental lake on the property.

1910 July 15 Irvington’s The Virginia Citizen

1910 July 15 Irvington’s The Virginia Citizen

It seems that the summer of 1910 was attracting many to Belle Grove and Walsingham to marvel at the success of Captain Jack. Another visitor, Professor Carrier visited the plantations in August. There he found that Captain Jack had already two cuttings of alfalfa that season and was already cutting a third. He also explained that Captain Jack was expecting to get two more cuttings before the season was out.

In his inspection of the plantations, Professor Carrier reported that the word of the success of the crop had not been exaggerated. He praised Captain Jack’s method of farming and expected if others in the State followed suit, they too would meet with the same success.

1910 August 23 The Free Lance Star

1910 August 23 The Free Lance Star

In October, 1910, another social note from Belle Grove. Miss Annie Gwathmey paid a visit to her cousin, Miss Lille Overton Taylor at Belle Grove. I have noticed that the social notes of what I think are farm hands and their families seem to appear in smaller columns, while visitors of Captain Jack are writing in stand-alone articles.

1910 October 02 The Times-Dispatch

1910 October 02 The Times-Dispatch

Here we see that Captain Jack has received visitors in November, 1910. This large party of seven from California paid a visit to Fredericksburg to see the sites. I wonder what locations they would have seen. Was Kenmore Plantation open at that time for visitors? Or did they stop at the Rising Sun Tavern, owned by Charles Washington, brother of George. Or did they visit the battlefields that lay around Fredericksburg to see where past family and friend fought the Civil War?

1910 November 05 The Free Lance Star

1910 November 05 The Free Lance Star

In February, 1911, Miss Lilly Tayloe of Belle Grove had family from Richmond visit. Again, it is in a smaller column so I am assuming a wife of a farm hand. We will have to see with some more research.

1911 February 23 The Free Lance Star

1911 February 23 The Free Lance Star

The last newspaper article I found on Captain Jack was that of a fire in the barn at Belle Grove. The barn and 250 tons of alfalfa were lost along with a large amount of farming equipment. The origin of the fire was never known. It resulted in a $10,000 loss. Captain Jack did not have insurance on the barn or equipment.

1911 July 20 Free Lance Star

1911 July 20 Free Lance Star

From here the trail grows cold. I have not been able to find any other information on Captain Jack. We know that he sold the plantations in 1911, but do not know what month. Could this fire have been the “straw that broke the camel’s back”? Could he not recover from this loss? Maybe he was ready to do move to the next venture. Only time will tell as we hope to under the mystery of whom Captain Jack was and where he ended up.

To see more of Belle Grove Plantation

Please visit our Facebook Page!

Facebook Link

Posted by Michelle Darnell | in Belle Grove History | 39 Comments »

39 Comments on “Captain Jack”

  1. cmblake6 Says:

    The successes and failures can be fascinating to follow. It is a shame the knowledge path came to a halt. Did Captain Jack recover from the alfalfa and equipment loss? Fate can be a real b*tch!

  2. Thank you! I guess we are going to have to wait and see what his outcome is. I never know when the trail will jump back up and show a new lead!

  3. cmblake6 Says:

    This could be vry interesting. And obviously the Plantation never burned down. 🙂

  4. vanbraman Says:

    I maybe have a clue for you. Captain Jack may have had a slightly different last name. There is a J.F. Jacques who was on the 1900 census in Los Angeles County and was a farmer. He was born in 1849 in Illinois. He is also listed in the same place as John F. Jacques in 1910, but the clipping from 1910 still says he is of Los Angeles and there is nobody close to this name in Virginia. Just some thoughts :-).

  5. vanbraman Says:

    Also, see: scroll down to P-97 J. F. Jack Collection, 1906

  6. Okay now, you are getting ahead of my postings! I have the collection already. I received it from the Seaver Center last year. This collection is to be my next posting. But thank you for doing some of the research!

  7. Wow that could be a lead to him. I will see if that leads us anywhere from here. Thank you so much!

  8. vanbraman Says:

    OK, scratch my Jacques theory. There is a Jno F Jack on the 1910 Census for Los Angeles. He is 53 years old, born in Ohio and married to Bella W. who is 39 and also born in Ohio.

  9. Ok, maybe that could be him! This is getting to be a lot of fun! I love to work with others to find the answer to our mysteries!

  10. augusta Says:

    I loved this story of successful farming in the days before Monsanto!

  11. Thank you! It has been like pulling teeth find out about him, but we are not going to stop until the whole story is there.

  12. colmel Says:

    Hey, there! With regard to Mrs. C. Shirley Carter and her son, back in the day, women were most often referred to as Mrs. then their husband’s names. Married ladies’ first names were rarely used, especially in print. Therefore, I would surmise that her son C. Shirley Carter would have taken his father’s full name but eschewed the “Jr.”

  13. Thank you! That is something I didn’t think of!

  14. The fire could well have spelled the end of Mr. Jack’s Virgina adventures. A $10,000 loss in 1911 is likely the equivalent of at least $1 million today, when adjusted for inflation. He may have had to sell the property or take some other dramatic step to stay afloat financially.

  15. Thank you! That is what I was thinking too!

  16. Such fascinating history. I love reading the old social columns from days gone bye from our area.

  17. I do too. Wouldn’t it be wonderful if we had them again. Of course we have our version of them called Tabloid Magazines. But they aren’t the same.

  18. Jane Sadek Says:

    Very interesting. I can’t help but wonder why he left California in the first place. There must be a novel in there somewhere.

  19. Could be! But we have to uncover who he is first! Thank you!

  20. John Says:

    So interesting, this era has fascinated me for years. Great reading!

  21. Thank you! I loved that they took to the river to get the word out!

  22. hermitsdoor Says:

    Unusual for someone to come from CA to VA at that time. Even with the transcontinental railroad, traveling coast to coast was not an easy or inexpensive task.

  23. That is so true. There has to be a story there.

  24. Interesting that he came from California to Virginia to teach farming. About fifteen years later, my father’s family would go from Tennessee to California to buy farms in the Central Valley to try cotton ranching. The ones who stayed in CA got rich, but my grandfather didn’t like it here and went back to Tennessee after a year. Homesick for the mountains, I’ve always thought. I have forgotten if Belle Grove still has any work farms left as part of the estate.

  25. Belle Grove is still a working farm. The fields outside the land the Mansion stands on are leased to a farmer to work. But what a wonderful history your family has!

  26. David Says:

    A very interesting history. I would be interested how Captain Jack acquired the “Captain” title. I know you really don’t need to serve in the military or have a nautical background to be addressed as such. I’m looking forward to reading more.

  27. I have thought of that too. I was looking in the military records to see if I could find something about him, but had no luck!

  28. What fun to live amongst so much history! Great research which made for a wonderful post! Very interesting.

  29. Thank you! It is wonderful and it endless. Just when we think we have found all of it, something new springs up.

  30. Have you found any reports of a mysterious blue box showing up at around the time Captain Jack disappears from the historical record of the area? 😉

  31. Okay, you have me lost. Blue Box? I am assuming it has something to do with Captain Jack Swarrow?

  32. Close — Captain Jack Harkness from “Doctor Who”. Sorry to be such a nerd! 😀

  33. Oh haha! No worries.

  34. Mara Kaktins Says:

    Fantastic research! Thumbs up!

  35. Thank you! I just wish we knew more about him personally. Where did he go is the biggest question.

  36. drowqueen Says:

    Your posts are always fun to read and remind me of my research into my own family history. I would run into geneaology dead-ends and stopped for a while, but I really need to find my answers.

  37. I feel the same way. But I find when I step back and come back letter, I discover something that I over looked and it leads me off again. Good Luck with your search!

  38. swabby429 Says:

    That’s quite an amazing collection of clippings and history.

  39. Thank you!